Planet of the Apemen – Battle for Earth: Neanderthal (2/2)

The Good Guys

The second programme of BBC’s Planet of the Apemen docudrama series is slightly less risible than the first.  You can see my previous post on the encounter between Homo sapiens and Homo erectus here.

In this programme, the plucky sapiens encounter Neanderthals in southern France, 32,000 years ago.  Bigger, stronger, and with a larger brain capacity than sapiens, they had already been there for 500,000 years when sapiens first encountered them.  Long enough to have evolved a paler skin colour in response to the cooler northern climate.  I love it that we all came out of Africa and were once dark-skinned.  The perfect fact to irritate white supremacists.

They had language, but hadn’t evolved to efficiently produce sounds, so that spoken communication would not have been as complex as it was among sapiens.  And they formed family units in which the sick were cared for, and the dead were buried with wreaths of flowers.  This last point wasn’t made in the programme and perhaps should have been.  Their weapons technology was different from sapiens – thick thrusting spears as opposed to thin, light throwing spears – which was reflected in the style of hunting.  Sapiens would kill animals from a distance, while Neanderthals would charge up and knock them over, finishing them off with a thrusting spear.  Clearly a much more dangerous strategy.  And the essential difference between British and American football.

As in the first programme, the experts talked about the relative strengths of the two species, and the drama demonstrated what they talked about.  One expert in both the programmes hurled spears at, or stabbed, a dead pig to demonstrate the effects of different weapons.  I think the pig should have got a mention in the credits.

My problem with this docudrama is that we get short changed in two ways.  The documentary isn’t as interesting or complex as it could be, tied down as it is to being a gloss for the drama.  And the drama is naff.  Simplistic, politically correct, and so airbrushed that you can imagine it as an advertisement for an exotic holiday.  Just as the village at the end of Homo erectus was Club Med, the encampment in Neanderthal is an idealised version of a Native American campsite, complete with teepees.

And that’s just the props.  The actors are all thoroughly photogenic, except the ones playing Neanderthals.  Even so, the surviving Neanderthal could probably get the starring role in a Tarzan movie.

But it’s the political correctness that sticks out like a vegetarian at a Cattle Ranchers’ Association dinner.  Essentially, sapiens unwittingly move into Neanderthal terrritory, and the Neanderthals kill the heroine’s brother, thus setting off an inter-species feud that ends badly for the Neanderthals.  We’re told in the postscript that within a few thousand years their population declined disastrously and they only managed to hang on in Gibraltar, becoming extinct 24,000 years ago.

The heroine, Byana, is an stone age protofeminist, railing against the fact that only men get to hunt and not wanting to marry the man from another group that her father has chosen for her.  Byana really wants to be a hunter, to the point where she blows their chance of killing a horse by chucking her own spear at it and missing.  So she gets her brother, the one later killed by Neanderthals, to teach her.  From their practice session, it’s clear that Byana couldn’t hit the side of a woolly mammoth.  Yet when she gets her hands on a spear-thrower, suddenly she becomes a dead shot.  After the scene of Byana rejecting her traditional role as wife and mother, we get another expert waxing lyrical about the advantages of gender specialization and division of labour.  So you know this rebellion is a flash in the pan.

Byana is also the conscience of the sapiens.  While she understandably calls them “monsters” after her brother’s murder, she lets a wounded Neanderthal live.  Coincidentally, this is the Hollywood type I mentioned earlier.  When the victorious sapiens find him in the Neanderthal encampment, she pretends to kill him, and moments later you see him limping off toward extinction.  You’d think the other sapiens would have noticed the absence of a body.

But political correctness doesn’t end with Byana.  Her prospective mate is told by Byana’s father that they will be united the next day.  He is prepared to withdraw from the arrangement, saying that Byana doesn’t want to be a wife, she wants to be a hunter.  The perfect 21st century man.  Byana, however, has changed her mind.  “Together stronger,” she says, kissing the fertility symbol she carries.  “Together stronger” also echoes her father’s wish for the two sapiens groups to join forces for mutual benefit.  Presumably with Byana as familial glue.

I said at the beginning that this programme is slightly less risible than the last.  But only because the events are more plausible, without of course the 21st century attitudes embodied in the narrative.  The word “ethnocentric” doesn’t just spring to mind, it leaps into physical existence and rips chunks out of your leg.

As for the documentary aspect, its function is to pimp out a ludicrous drama.  This is a fascinating subject.  I’m deeply interested in human origins and how we might have interacted with other hominid species.  But it needs a proper, scientifically rigorous documentary to do it justice.  This one tries to be half entertainment and fails miserably.

8 thoughts on “Planet of the Apemen – Battle for Earth: Neanderthal (2/2)

  1. Really interesting blog! Check out mines and let me know what you think. I’ll take all the advice I can get 🙂

  2. I’m feeling quite sorry now that I missed this, sounds hilarious. The “We all started off black” thing always tickles me too, as you say the perfect antidote to white supremacists. On a slightly different tack – have you been watching the History Cold Case series, that’s had some fascinating insights into the past?

    • I did like it on a comedic level (think unwitting mockumentary), and it presented the opportunity for a really exhilarating rant. The BBC is usually so good at documentaries that I don’t often get the chance.

      I’ve been watching History Cold Case. A bit formulaic, but I enjoy the skellingtons and how the team fleshes out their lives. It’s a big plus that they’re based in Dundee, the spiritual home of this blog.

      I have not forgotten the 666 Challenge. The Black Dog started chewing up the furniture just as I was getting into my stride. Now it’s mostly house trained, but still hasn’t learned the trick of letting me sit down and lose myself in a book. Except at the laundrette. I’ve been working my way through one book for several months now.

      Getting better, though. It’s horrible to lose one of your greatest pleasures.

      • Glad to hear that the black dog has started dog training classes, mine takes me in the other direction – I start to read compulsively. All very well, except that I hardly take in a word I read(!) Wonder why the laundrette works??

  3. Battle of the Neandethals has the makings of a terrific soap opera; was it not a pilot? I agree Byana was hilarious, but I had quite a bit of time for her dad. Did anyone else notice the similarities with the terminated sci-fi drama ‘Outcasts’? In later episodes, we might get to see how some Neanderthal DNA ended up in our genome. Can’t wait…

    As for History Cold Cases – Time Team with surgical masks – I do like it, though yes, a very regular motif pattern with sections from the narrators script identical among episodes. The ‘staff’, though are real experts with experience as serious as it gets: boundless respect for them. Xanthi is… eh…yes.

    I note Dundee Uni has rocketed up the world university rankings, mainly on the back of Medical Biology. Nice to see real success in the “City of Discovery”; a slogan which for too long drew a smirk.

    • Yes, I was rather hoping Byana and Tarzan would shed some light on the Neanderthal DNA in the sapiens genome.

      Had to google Xanthe to make sure we were talking about the same woman, but yes, she can have my skull any time she wants.

      I’ve been fascinated by Dundee ever since I heard about McGonagall. Only visited the place once, though, a few years ago when I still lived in America. Spent a blissful afternoon in the Library, looking at the original McGonagall manuscripts. Time for another visit now I live in Scotland.

  4. @Benregis

    “Glad to hear that the black dog has started dog training classes, mine takes me in the other direction – I start to read compulsively. All very well, except that I hardly take in a word I read(!) Wonder why the laundrette works??”

    I’d settle for that. Think the laundrette works because there’s nothing else to do except read. Anywhere else is a Piccadilly Circus of distractions. The obvious solution is to do my laundry more often. Or else fly more often. But that works out a bit pricey.

  5. ….Actually….we all had white skin, yes, even the “black” Africans…when we were covered in hair…then we started to lose the hair and the skin started to tan to protect itself. Remember even black Africans have white palms and feet soles. Tanning came later…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s